| Player Name | Pos | Team | Actual Points |
| Vanderjagt, Mike | K | Ind | 143 |
| Elam, Jason | K | Den | 139 |
| Wilkins, Jeff | K | StL | 135 |
| Brown, Kris | K | Hou | 134 |
| Akers, David | K | Phi | 126 |
| Edinger, Paul | K | Chi | 125 |
| Carney, John | K | NO | 123 |
| Feely, Jay | K | Atl | 123 |
| Vinatieri, Adam | K | NE | 122 |
| Stover, Matt | K | Bal | 120 |
| Janikowski, Sebastia | K | Oak | 119 |
| Peterson, Todd | K | Pit | 118 |
| Hall, John | K | NYJ | 117 |
| Longwell, Ryan | K | GB | 113 |
| Conway, Brett | K | Was | 112 |
| Andersen, Morten | K | KC | 108 |
| Cortez, Jose | K | SF | 107 |
| Lindell, Rian | K | Sea | 105 |
| Nedney, Joe | K | Ten | 104 |
| Kasay, John | K | Car | 102 |
| Gramatica, Martin | K | TB | 102 |
| Hanson, Jason | K | Det | 100 |
| Dawson, Phil | K | Cle | 99 |
| Mare, Olindo | K | Mia | 98 |
| Richey, Wade | K | SD | 94 |
| Hollis, Mike | K | Buf | 89 |
| Rackers, Neil | K | Cin | 80 |
| Anderson, Gary | K | 80 | |
| Gramatica, Bill | K | Ari | 79 |
| Arians, Jake | K | 56 | |
| Seder, Tim | K | Dal | 48 |
| Hilbert, Jon | K | 47 | |
| Christie, Steve | K | SD | 35 |
| Graham, Shayne | K | 27 | |
| Oglesby, Cedric | K | 23 | |
| Brien, Doug | K | Min | 19 |
| Daluiso, Brad | K | 11 | |
| Holmes, Jaret | K | Jax | 1 |
