CDNOW - warning review
while green day has been typecast as a punk rock band
(green hair will do that to a group), it's actually much closer to an
unadorned power pop band. its songs are quick, catchy, heavy on melody,
and suited to harmony. the band never strays into elaborate concepts or
ill-defined self-importance. singer billie joe armstrong keeps a sense
of humor about himself at all times, and while his slightly british
accent is a bizarre affectation (though british music fans have likely
considered their bands' american accents to be just as odd), it never
seems more than a homage to the clash.
green day has never managed to move beyond harmless pop. none of punk's
rage -- whether actual or imagined -- stirs within it. this allows armstrong,
the songwriter, to turn it up a notch, but this adherence to bright,
accessible sounds also threatens to turn green day into the sort of band
that would fit nicely on a dawson's creek soundtrack.
even so, armstrong shows an impressive knowledge of rock history,
quoting petula clarks's "downtown" in the melody of "waiting"
and sandwiching the kinks' "a well respected man" riff
alongside the who's "my generation" power chords for "jackass."
the creep-show organ of "misery" is a nice touch, while the
folkie harmonica riff of "hold on" adds a nice garage rock
tone. but, as the three-chord rock of "church on sunday" and
"deadbeat" indicate, green day is best when it simply lets
itself fly.
rob o'connor
|
|
|