Reprinted with permission of the Omaha World-Herald

Published Wednesday

November 17, 1999

Beverage Deposit, Boat Rules Are Heated Issues

BY JULIE ANDERSON

WORLD-HERALD STAFF WRITER

The tide of public opinion Tuesday went against a mandatory deposit on cans and bottles and against restrictions on airboats on Nebraska's rivers. Both issues were subjects of hearings in Omaha by the Legislature's Natural Resources Nebraska Committee. Legislature State Sen. Curt Bromm of Wahoo said an interim study on a proposed deposit on cans and bottles was intended to determine whether the state is doing all it can to reduce litter and to reduce the amount of trash going to landfills. Bromm said he doesn't know whether a bottle bill will be introduced in the Legislature. Bromm called the idea a " 10-cent incentive to recycle" that has doubled recycling rates for beverage containers in states with deposits. Bromm noted that pop-bottle recycling in Nebraska has slipped. The state's annual recycling rate has reached 16 percent, he said, but the tons of trash going to landfills continues to increase. "I'm not sure we're winning the battle," he said. But recyclers, a grocer and a convenience store official opposed the deposit proposal, each for different reasons. Kay Stevens, executive director of the Nebraska State Recycling Association, said a deposit on glass and aluminum containers would upset the recycling network in the state. A 1979 law taxes manufacturers, wholesalers and retailers of food, beverages, cigarettes, paper products and other items. The money collected from those taxes, now about $1.1 million a year, goes to clean up litter, recycling programs and public education. "Nebraskans, as you've noticed, don't like mandatory anything," Stevens said. Stevens recommended a more comprehensive approach, possibly a system by which people pay fees for garbage disposal based on how much trash they toss. People would save money by recycling, she said. John Allen of Hy-Vee Food and Drug Stores said food safety is the basis of his concern about a deposit law. Having worked for Hy-Vee in Iowa, Allen said he is familiar with how that state's bottle law works. Bringing empty containers into food stores creates health concerns and adds to stores' labor costs, he said. Iowa, one of the 10 states that mandate deposits, requires customers to pay a 5-cent deposit on each container, refundable when the empty container is returned.

Boat Rules Are Heated Issues

A study of the impact of airboats operating on the Platte River drew about 100 people from as far away as North Platte, overflowing the committee's hearing room at the Chalco Hills Lake Recreation Area. The study was proposed by State Sen. Dan Lynch of Omaha after he was contacted by constituents concerned about the boats' noise. However, a Lynch aide said the study was not a request for a ban or restrictions on airboats.

Nick Clawson of Omaha, who wrote to Lynch, said airboats ruined a canoeing trip his family and friends took on the Platte last summer from North Bend to Fremont. "It kind of ruins the natural beauty of the river," Clawson said. Bruce Clawson, Nick's father, said he wondered how the noise affected wildlife and homeowners.

Jim McDermott, director of the Nebraska Airboat Association, said the group has been working with state officials to address the noise issue. The Nebraska Game and Parks Commission gave airboaters a year to muffle the boats' exhaust systems, and about 95 percent of the group's 300-plus members have done so, McDermott said. He said airboaters are working with the commission to monitor two endangered and threatened species on the Platte, the Least Tern and the Piping Plover, and they help provide search and rescue assistance to local fire departments.

John Miyoshi, general manager of the Lower Platte North Natural Resources District in Wahoo, said both the NRD and the Lower Platte River Corridor Alliance oppose legislation affecting airboat use on the Platte without the agreement of the airboaters association. "We see airboats as a tool we can use for managing natural resources," he said.