2.1 Born to Hang
Changes all round at the WayStation, a new rider and cook join the riders.

2.2 Ghosts
Rachel is wanted for the murder of a man who killed her husband. Hey Teaspoon, Lou's a girl!

2.3 Dead Ringer
Jimmy becomes the target of a bounty hunter after he's framed for robbery and murder.

2.4 Blood Moon
Sweetwater is quarantined after an outbreak which may be cholera.

2.5 Pride and Prejudice
What seems like a good deed on Buck's part leads to tragedy.

2.6 The Littlest Cowboy
A dying boy visits his heroes, the riders of the Pony Express.

2.7 Blood Money
When Kid turns in a man to justice after he tries to steal Katy, he unwittingly turns him in to be murdered.

2.8 Requiem for a Hero
Cody meets his hero who has given up his will to live.

2.9 Bad Company
Jimmy accidentally kills a woman, which prompts him leave the Pony Express.

2.10. Star Light, Star Bright
Jimmy rescues an old prospector from an ambush, who repays the kindness by sharing his mine with the riders. Guest star: Brian Keith

2.11 The Play's the Thing
Cody joins a group of actors who plan to assassinate an important army general.

2.12 Judgement Day
While mourning the death of Hezekiah Horne, Cody joins up with a preacher who seeks justice.

2.13 Kansas
Noah is captured by slavers and the riders must find him before he's sold into slavery. Guest star:Richard Roundtree.

2.14 The Peacemakers
Jimmy falls for a member of a religious sect being persecuted by the townsfolk.

2.15 Daisy
Rachel's ex-partner arrives with his daughter while on the run.

2.16 Color Blind
On the rebound from Lou, Kid is attracted to Sweetwater's new schoolteacher.

2.17 Old Scores
Ike meets one of the men responsible for his family's massacre, and tries to find a way to prove it and gets even. The other riders chase down a monster.

2.18 The Talisman
When an old friend calls for help, Teaspoon takes some of the riders to Mexico.

2.19 A Noble Chase
Jimmy works with - and against - bounty hunter Jake Colter to bring in a bank robber.

2.20 Face of the Enemy
An old friend of Teaspoon's accuses Buck of staging an ambush to kill army personnel.

2.21 The Exchange Pt. 1
When Teaspoon is given a prisoner to transport to the Army for hanging, Amanda is kidnapped and held to ransom.

2.22 The Exchange Pt. 2
As above.