Mystic River
Now Playing: ***** Five stars out of possible five
Nearly two weeks later, and I still can't think about "Mystic River," even in passing, without getting a small, sharp shudder. I can't remember the last time a movie left me with this strong a sense of purely contemporary human emotion: love, pity, hatred, desire, despair. It's all there, in the story of three boys who grow up to be three men whose lives entwine in tragic ways.

Sean, Johnny and Dave are just three kids playing street hockey when we meet them, just before impressionable Dave is talked into a "police" car for a trip that changes his life forever. The main body of the movie picks up years later, when Johnny's teen-age daughter is horrifically murdered. Sean, who has grown up to become a policeman, is working the case, which tugs the three men back together.
I've never been a Sean Penn fan, but his performance in "Mystic River" is nothing short of excellent. He displays the kind of tough inner grit that's letting him stay "in control" of the neighborhood while keeping it covered with a much more easy-going layer of family man and small business owner. His utter soul-level grief at the hideous death of his daughter is almost too raw to watch, and he never strikes a false note throughout.
Kevin Bacon has been wasting himself as a performer, judging by the tightly nuanced performance he gives in "Mystic River." His cop, Sean, is trying to live by the easy-going route, but unspoken problems have torn his marriage apart and his one-sided attempts to get back in touch with his runaway wife are painful to watch.
But the real revelation in "Mystic River" is Tim Robbins as the deeply damaged Dave. I've been a Tim Robbins fan since forever, but even I was amazed at this performance. Director Clint Eastwood has either pulled from or allowed to emerge from Robbins a performance of absolute fearful despair. His Dave is a man living on the ragged edge of one last little bit of sanity. Even physically, the performance is a work of genius, as Robbins, the largest of the three main characters, seems almost to fold and shrink into himself in every scene. It's almost as if he were trying to make himself disappear.
"Mystic River" is something not seen often in contemporary American cinema - a classic tragedy. Nothing is overblown, nothing is racheted beyond believeability, and yet the overall impact is absolutely stunning. The last time I remember being this deeply moved by a movie was with Atom Egoyan's "The Sweet Hereafter."
This is a movie that must be seen. Do yourself a favor and go. You won't regret it.
48 days until The Return of the King!