Melanie and Anthony were never "official" so I guess no-one really knows what happened. Doesn't mean to say there was nothing though...
I'm not thinking along the lines of the Lotus Flower tattoo, that doesn't prove anything. The lyrics that hey write are far more interesting...
Its pretty obvious that Melanie wrote never Be The Same Again about Anthony . She admits it was about an American guy - how many other Americans has she been linked to? Never Be The Same Again is fairly straight forward, a "will we, wont we" situation. Melanie admits he was a close friend so that figures.
Anthony said one of the tracks he wrote for the 1999 album Californication, was written about Melanie. After listening to the album quite a few times its prety obvious that the song is Emit Remmus. The song is clearly written about an English girl. Why is it definately Melanie? Well, certain lyrics describe her perfectly. "The look she used was green and sharp" Melanie's green eyes. "Felony sends me all the gold in your smile" Melanie's gold tooth. Coincidence? I think not.
When you compare the two songs, they were both written around the same time, when Melanie and Anthony were both in Los Angeles. Melanie admits going out for dinner with Anthony around the same time. Must of been something there...