| Yearly NSL Awards | ||||
| Year | MVP | Nolan Ryan | Rookie/Yr | Manager/Yr |
| (Al Rapp award) | (Dick Silar award) | (Gideon Burnham award) | Rich Pray award) | |
| 1979 | Rice Yk | J.D.Martinez IC | ||
| 1980 | Winfield Cle | Kravec Cle | ||
| 1981 | Cooper Cle | Carlton TMI | ||
| 1982 | Foster IC | McCatty Chi | ||
| 1983 | Oliver GBr | Sanderson IC | Ripken PC | J.Chalfant PC |
| 1984 | Dale Murphy JG | Soto Deu | Strawberry Sas | Hensel Deu |
| 1985 | Mattingly LC | Gooden WM | Gooden WM | Pray GBr |
| 1986 | Mattingly LC | Gooden WM | Coleman VT | G.Burnham GM |
| 1987 | Mattingly LC | M.Witt SA | Joyner Jer | Whitney Har |
| 1988 | Mattingly LC | Clemens Cle | McGwire Men | Brown Bro |
| 1989 | Galarraga GM | Browning EY | Grace WW | Ashby TMI |
| 1990 | Sierra Yk | Saberhagen GBr | Olson PC | Silar Yk |
| 1991 | Fielder NEK | D.Stewart NE | S.Alomar WW | Mickley EY |
| 1992 | Fielder NEK | Clemens GBr | J.Gonzalez Cre | J.Barnes KeC |
| 1993 | Daulton Yk | G.Maddux Lon | Lofton NE | Waller NE |
| 1994 | Thomas Pa | Burkett Der | Piazza Wil | E.Burnham Der |
| 1995 | Bagwell PC | Z.Smith EY | Hamelin LC | Wilburn MC |
| 1996 | Belle GM | R.Johnson Cre | C.Jones Far | Mann Cre |
| 1997 | Galarraga GM | Smoltz EY | Renteria Lon | J.Chalfant PC |
| 1998 | Griffy WW | P.J.Martinez MC | Garciaparra VT | R.Chalfant WR |
| 1999 | McGwire Cre | A.Leiter Cre | Grieve PC | Wilburn MC |
| 2000 | Jeter WW | R.Johnson Cre | J.W.Zimmerman NE | Becker Lon |
| 2001 | Helton Cle | P.J.Martinez MC | Ankiel GM | Mann Cre |
| 2002 | Bonds EY | Mulder Cle | Suzuki Cle | Lanphear Jer |
| 2003 | Helton Cle | P.J.Martinez Yk | Hinske WW | R.Chalfant WR |
| 2004 | Pujols Cro | Pineiro Cle | Teixiera Joh | Cross Cro |
| 2005 | Pujols Cro | R.Johnson Yk | Holliday Joh | Waller NE |
| 2006 | Teixiera Joh | Oswalt IN | Street Key | Pray GBr |
| 2007 | D.Ortiz IN | Oswalt IN | Liriano Cle | N.Davis Alb |
| 2008 | H.Ramirez Lon | Sabathia Jer | Braun VT | D.Wilburn Dun |
| 2009 | H.Ramirez Lon | Lincecum Cre | Longoria GM | G.Burnham GM |
| 2010 | P.Fielder Alb | Carpenter Cro | Cahill Joh | C.Brown Kal |
| 2011 | Hamilton Cle | Fe.Hernandez Dun | G.Sanchez Dun | A.Rapp Cle |
| 2012 | M.Cabrera VT | Halladay Cle | Freeman IN | D.Burnham VT |
| 2013 | M.Cabrera VT | R.A.Dickey VT | Cespedes Gle | D.Burnham VT |
| 2014 | M.Cabrera VT | Wainwright Alb | Puig Gle | B.Chalfant Mun |
| 2015 | J.Abreu Cre | Fe.Hernandez Cre | J.Abreu Cre | D.Mann Cre |
| 2016 | Arenado Key | Greinke Key | Bryant NE | Barnes Key |
| 2017 | Altuve Alb | J.Fernandez SL | G.Sanchez Cro | D.Wilburn Dun |
| 2018 | Blackmon SL | Kluber Kal | Bellinger NE | J.Barnes KeC |
| 2019 | J.D.Martinez Alb | Kluber Kal | J.Soto Cre | B.Wilburn MC |
| 2020 | Bellinger Coa | G.Cole Mar | Soroka Coa | D.Wilburn Dun |