| NSL | All- Star | Results | |||||
| WP | LP | Save | |||||
| 1979 | West 4 | vs East 1 | at Ohio | Matlack | Goltz | Brusstar | |
| 1980 | West 3 | at East 1 | at Green Mt. | Kern | Augustine | ||
| 1981 | West 3 | at East 2 | at York | Garvin | Minton | 11 innings | |
| 1982 | East 4 | at West 3 | at Iron City | Carlton | Reardon | Fingers | |
| 1983 | West 7 | at East 5 | at TMI | Soto | Rogers | Quisenberry | |
| 1984 | West 3 | vs East 1 | at Saskatchewan | Soto | Stieb | Orosco | |
| 1985 | West 12 | vs East 2 | at Parker City | Andujar | Stieb | ||
| 1986 | West 9 | vs East 5 | at James Gang | Stieb | Cliburn | ||
| 1987 | East 4 | vs West 0 | at Vermont | Higuera | M.Witt | ||
| 1988 | West 10 | at East 1 | at James Gang | Cox | Key | ||
| 1989 | West 4 | vs East 1 | at East York | Leibrandt | Moyer | ||
| 1990 | East 11 | vs West 6 | at Jericho | Browning | Drabek | ||
| 1991 | East 8 | at West 5 | at Wolf's Wizards | D.Stewart | Gullickson | ||
| 1992 | West 11 | at East 7 | at New England | D.Martinez | Clemens | Lee Smith | |
| 1993 | East 4 | vs West 2 | at Cleveland | Appier | Smiley | Ro.Hernandez | |
| 1994 | East 4 | vs West 0 | at Lamoille County | Appier | G.Maddux | Ward | |
| 1995 | East 9 | at West 3 | at Pennsylvania | McDonald | G.Maddux | ||
| 1996 | West 8 | at East 2 | at Magic City | F.Castillo | Appier | ||
| 1997 | West 9 | vs East 8 | at Keystone | Ro.Hernandez | Wohlers | ||
| 1998 | East 1 | vs West 0 | at E.Hardwick Giants | Clemens | Schilling | Shaw | |
| 1999 | VT 7 | at IN 2 | at Farmland | D.Wells | C.Finley | game #1 | |
| 1999 | VT 0 | at Pa 6 | at Farmland | Schilling | Glavine | game #2 | |
| 2000 | Schmidt 7 | at Cooper 1 | at Longstown | P.Martinez | R.Johnson | ||
| 2001 | Cooper 6 | at Schmidt 5 | at Green Mountain | Benitez | D'Amico | Koch | 10 innings |
| 2002 | Schmidt 7 | at Cooper 11 | at White River | Kile | Miulder | ||
| 2003 | Schmidt 2 | at Cooper 7 | at Cleveland | M.Morris | Appier | ||
| 2004 | Schmidt 3 | at Cooper 1 | at Creekside | M.Redman | Piniero | Gagne | |
| 2005 | Cooper 6 | at Schmidt 5 | at Vermont | Schilling | Oswalt | Nathan | |
| 2006 | Cooper 4 | at Schmidt 8 | at Crosstown | Carpenter | J.Patterson | ||
| 2007 | Schmidt 11 | at Cooper 5 | at York | Webb | Halladay | ||
| 2008 | Scmidt 0 | at Cooper 4 | at Wolf's Wizards | Burnett | Verlander | no hitter | |
| 2009 | Schmidt 5 | at Cooper 4 | at East York | Nathan | Lindstrom | 12 innings | |
| 2010 | Schmidt 4 | at Cooper 2 | at Canaan | Wainwright | Hoffman | M.Rivera | |
| 2011 | Cooper 2 | at Schmidt 4 | at Sparrow Lake | Venters | Kuo | 13 innings | |
| 2012 | Schmidt 3 | at Cooper 10 | at Muncie | Beckett | Marcum | ||
| 2013 | Cooper 11 | at Schmidt 3 | at Indiana | Price | M.Cain | ||
| 2014 | Schmidt 4 | at Cooper 7 | at Keystone | Rosenthal | Feldman | Cotts | |
| 2015 | Cooper 1 | at Schmidt 2 | at Duneland | Kluber | Archer | Storen | |
| 2016 | Cooper 1 | at Schmidt 3 | at Glenville | Arrieta | Greinke | H.Rondon | |
| 2017 | Cooper 8 | at Schmidt 5 | at Albany | J.Fernandez | A.Sanchez | ||
| 2018 | Schmidt 4 | at Cooper 6 | at Marietta | Dickey | Leone | Jansen | |
| 2019 | Schmidt 5 | at Cooper 3 | at Creekside | Bauer | Nola | E.Diaz | |
| 2020 | Schmidt 5 | at Cooper 4 | at Kalamazoo | Bieber | Gonzales | N.Anderson | |
| 2021 | Cooper 8 | at Schmidt 5 | at Green Mt. | Keuchel | Bieber | N.Anderson | |
| NSL | All-League | Results | |||||
| 1988 | West 7 | vs East 4 | at Cleveland | ||||
| 1989 | East 0 | at West 3 | at York | ||||
| 1990 | West 2 | vs East 1 | at Gulf Breeze | ||||
| 1991 | East 6 | vs West 4 | at Lamoille County | ||||
| 1992 | East 3 | at West 4 | at York | ||||
| 1993 | East 4 | at West 0 | at Gulf Breeze | ||||
| 1994 | West 12 | vs East 8 | at York | ||||
| 1995 | West 11 | at East 6 | at Lamoille County | ||||
| 1996 | East 8 | at West 4 | at York | ||||
| 1997 | East 7 | at West 4 | at Gulf Breeze | ||||
| 1998 | East 3 | at West 5 | at Wolf's Wizards | ||||
| 1999 | VT 10 | at IN 2 | at Cleveland | game #1 | |||
| 1999 | VT 6 | at Pa 7 | at Cleveland | game #2 | |||
| 2000 | Schmidt 4 | at Cooper 5 | at Gulf Breeze | ||||
| 2001 | Schmidt 3 | at Cooper 7 | at Keystone | ||||
| 2002 | Schmidt 8 | at Cooper 9 | at Gulf Breeze | 12 innings | |||
| 2003 | Schmidt 3 | at Cooper 5 | at Keystone | 10 innings | |||
| 2004 | Schmidt 10 | at Cooper 2 | at Cleveland | ||||
| 2005 | Schmidt 7 | at Cooper 6 | at Gulf Breeze | ||||
| 2006 | Cooper 9 | at Schmidt 5 | at Oneonta, NY | ||||
| 2007 | Cooper 5 | at Schmidt 1 | at Sparrow Lake | ||||
| 2008 | Schmidt 2 | at Cooper 3 | at York | ||||
| 2009 | Cooper 3 | at Schmidt 7 | at Gulf Breeze | ||||
| 2010 | Cooper 4 | at Schmidt 1 | at York | ||||
| 2011 | Cooper 7 | at Schmidt 1 | at Gulf Breeze | ||||
| 2012 | Schmidt 4 | at Cooper 11 | at York | ||||
| 2013 | Cooper 3 | at Schmidt 4 | at Gulf Breeze | ||||
| 2014 | Schmidt 13 | at Cooper 3 | at York | ||||
| 2015 | Schmidt 8 | at Cooper 1 | at Gulf Breeze | ||||
| 2016 | Schmidt 3 | at Cooper 2 | at Gulf Breeze | ||||
| 2017 | Schmidt 9 | at Cooper 2 | at Gulf Breeze | ||||
| 2018 | Cooper 2 | at Schmidt 1 | at Gulf Breeze | ||||
| 2019 | Schmidt 6 | at Cooper 1 | at Gulf Breeze | ||||
| 2020 | Schmidt 3 | at Cooper 1 | at Gulf Breeze |