| Player | Week 1 | Week 2 | Week 3 | Week 4 |
| BulletHose | Dale Earnhardt Jr. (11th) | Jeff Gordon | ||
| Dizzy | Greg Biffel (37th) | |||
| Toggo | NA | NA | NA | |
| JP | Kyle Petty (27th) | Christian Fittipaldi | ||
| Fool | Jeff Gordon (2nd) | |||
| Or | Rusty Wallace (8th) | |||
| Chimera | Micheal Waltrip (13th) | |||
| Llama | Matt Kenseth (14th) | Kevin Harvick | ||
| Matrix | Matt Kenseth (14th) | |||
| Rogue | Tony Stewart (12th) | |||
| Lt. Dan | Rusty Wallace (8th) | Bill Elliot |
1. Fool (48)
2. Or (42)
3. Lt. Dan (42)
4. BulletHose (39)
5. Rogue (38)
6. Chimera (37)
7. Llama (36)
8. Matrix (36)
9. JP (23)
10. Dizzy (13)
11. Toggo (0) *Eliminated*
