The Walrus Strikes again, and things get even stupider
This guy must have taken Weird Al's song "Dare to be Stupid" a little too literally:
D and D and Me Part 3: Medieval Times-----------------------------------------------------
My email, to him:
Dear Mr. Barbeau,
As a former member of YRPG (and a girl) I have been following your "D&D and Me" series over a period of time, and witnessing some of the subsequent fallout. I was not grossly offended by the first two parts, as I considered them to be tongue-in-cheek, but I'm afraid that your third part has me baffled.
If you are going to express your opinion, then at the very least, let your readers in on what it is that you are writing about. Your third part accomplishes nothing but make you look like a childish backpeddler who doesn't want to give details of the actual fallout of the articles, but rather make up some moronic fictional representation of the truth. If you truly are a journalist, Mr. Barbeau, then you would apologize if you felt sorry, and write a REAL review of the club, or you would explain why you think there was nothing wrong with the original articles. Your poorly written third part just seems like a pathetic attempt to further bludgeon an already well-beaten dead horse.
Furthermore, (and I'd like to make this abundantly clear) comedy is best left to the people who can actually write it, and not those just making a pathetic attempt to "build themselves up, as a group and as individuals, at the expense of another similar group".
Sincerely,
Megan Swaine,
York University alumni, and still proud RPG gamer.
------------------------------------------------
In the process of making this post, I found this (and please read it all the way to the end):
Editor's Note, February 2006 IssueI admire this editor's response as being decent, and mature. Especially since he was 'threatened' by an offended gaming geek.
I will however, state here and now that I don't believe that there was 'supposed' to be three articles. I think the last article was the writer's pathetic attempt to cover his own ass. Which is why I'm going to leave my response the way it is. If the articles were meant to be fictional, then they should not have used the name of a real club, with real people. Period.
This whole thing was ridiculous to begin with, and both sides came out looking pretty shameful. You wanna know why I never wrote for a York publication? Here's a good example. Try getting heard through the caucophony of idiotic people who think they can write for the Onion, and who are trying to pad an issue.
Like for instance,
my first encounter with the Excaliber, main York publication. (THAT article was written many moons ago, so please take it as such)