Vs.
| Player | Everybody's Rival | Points | Player | Liberty City Lightning Birds | Points | |
| QB-Kerry Collins | 233 pass,1 td,1 fumble | 13.32 | QB-Jake Delhomme | 216 pass,2 td,13 run,1 fumble | 19.94 | |
| RB-Marshall Faulk | 108 run,3 td,2 rec,35 yds | 34.30 | RB-LaDanian Tomlinson | 106 run,1 td,5 rec,17 yds | 23.30 | |
| RB-Domanick Davis | 101 run,2 td,2 rec,27 yds | 26.80 | RB-Stephen Davis | 115 run | 11.50 | |
| WR-Randy Moss | 10 rec,160 yds,1 td,5 run,1 fumble | 30.50 | WR-Marvin Harrison | 7 rec,88 yds,1 td | 21.80 | |
| WR-Terrell Owens | 3 rec,23 yds | 5.30 | WR-Darrell Jackson | 8 rec,102 yds,2 td | 30.20 | |
| TE-Bubba Franks | 4 rec,32 yds,1 td | 13.20 | TE-Tony Gonzalez | 4 rec,28 yds,2 td | 18.80 | |
| DL-Dwight Freeney | 3 tackles,1 sack | 6.00 | DL-Simeon Rice | 1 tackle,1 assist | 1.50 | |
| DL-Adewale Ogunleye | 3 tackles,2 sacks | 9.00 | DL-Mike Rucker | 5 tackles,2 assists,1 sack,1 int | 12.00 | |
| LB-Brian Simmons | 6 tackles,2 assists,1 sack | 10.00 | LB-Al Wilson | 1 tackle,1 assist,1 fumble rec | 3.50 | |
| LB-Donnie Edwards | 8 tackles,4 assists | 10.00 | LB-Andra Davis | 9 tackles,2 assists,1 sack | 13.00 | |
| DB-Rodney Harrison | nothing | 0.00 | DB-Aaron Glenn | nothing | 0.00 | |
| DB-Brian Williams | 3 tackles | 3.00 | DB-Michael Lewis | 2 tackles | 2.00 | |
| K-Paul Edinger | 4 x-pts | 4.00 | K-Adam Vinatieri | 5 x-pts, 1 FG (43) | 9.00 | |
| TOTAL POINTS | 165.42 | TOTAL POINTS | 166.54 |