Albo family meets with Assistant Deputy Ministry of Health, Wendy Hill
TMTV/BCTV Kootenays - Posted Dec 7, 2006
Today a meeting was held at the request of Assistant Deputy Minister of Health, Wendy Hill, with some of the family of Frances and Alfred Albo, to evaluate IHAs implementation of Dr. Ballems recommendations.
After the meeting, Carol Albo noted that Although eleven much needed beds have been added in the area and 15 promised for 2008, we continue to feel patronized. IHA made piecemeal changes in an attempt to appease public outrage, rather than in a serious commitment to deliver reasonable service to seniors.
The issue of distrust by the community hasnt been resolved, said Jerome Albo, and such issues as KIRO Manor (a vacant IHA care facility) only add to this suspicion.
While Jim and Jerome Albo acknowledge that some positive actions resulted from changes implemented by IHA following the deaths of their parents, much more needs to be done to bridge the gap between communities and health authorities. Jim Albo concluded, The incompassionate and dictatorial methods of the IHA need to change, in order to bridge this gap.
press BACKGROUNDER - Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Seniors (SPCS)
Concerned Trail and area citizens formed the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Seniors (SPCS) in August in answer to public meetings and demonstrations.
In a recent SPCS press release, President Carol Albo said, While IHA claims to have addressed some of Dr. Ballem and Martin McMahons recommendations following the death of Frances Albo, we disagree. For example; three recommendations vital to SPCS concerns:
Recommendation #5 High Priority that additional transition beds be opened in the KBH service area. The purpose of these beds being to offer immediate strategies to relieve the exigencies arising from the acute, in-patient pressures.
Recommendation #6 High Priority that additional resources and spending be committed to further develop and enhance the range of community resources and services, particularly in the area of palliative care.
Recommendation #8 Medium Priority that we (IHA) consider supporting the planning and implementation of unique community-based solutions, which can assist in meeting the health challenges which confront the area.
In a News Release March 1, 2006 Minister of Health George Abbott, stated that more transition and palliative beds would be established in Trail.
It hasnt happened.
But those recommendations were addressed by the SPCS proposal: 6 palliative beds, 5 respite, 1 urgent assessment and 10 transition beds. The SPCS Transition Unit answers all those recommendations; it is community formed, community supported and would be community-based in an appropriate, economically feasible, already existing facility, Albo said
Instead, the Trail area has lost resources and contracted down the palliative services that were available prior to Dr. Ballems report. Cuts to local Hospice funding and lack of beds, has seen area palliative patients housed in hospital wards instead of private rooms.
Newly appointed Chair of the SPCS Communications Committee, Scott Leyland goes on to note that the final recommendation of Dr. Ballem was: Proceed with initiatives to effectively engage the communities with their health system. However, there was little community consultation and the resulting discontent led to an External Operational Review (funded by IHA) which confirmed that the direction was too dictatorial, without listening to the front-line workers, nor the community.
Some important results of the external review were:
1. The problem is not only what is communicated to the communities but the way it is communicated
2. There is no local control with all decisions made by the Chief Operating Officer (COO) or by decision makers in Kelowna
3. Stakeholders perceive the dominant management style to be oriented toward a command and control approach. Physicians echoed many of the general comments concerning leadership and management.
4. All groups spoke of not being heard or respected. Community stakeholders expressed significant distrust of IH who were widely seen as operating without regard to local interests.
An experienced cost analyst and people with backgrounds in engineering volunteered and were appointed by SPCS to do a fair and open feasibility comparison of combining half the IHA Wellness/Office with a 22 Bed Transition Unit proposed by the community for KIRO, using standard costing procedures.
The IHA pretended to take them seriously. Unfortunately the disrespect, contempt and deception continued
In a recent press release, the IHA notes they spent hundreds of staff-hours assisting the SPCS in their study.
But it wasn't until we accidentally
gained access to a full set of drawings, commissioned by the IHA,
prepared by DGBK - Architects in Vancouver, that we became aware
of the full extent of the IHA' s duplicity, notes Bill
Shepherd, member of the SPCS Feasibility Committee. Despite
statements that funding for KIRO had been postponed or put on
hold, the dates on these drawings (Oct 13 for costing/ Nov 21 for
funding) made it very obvious that IHA had gone ahead with their
plans for KIRO.
It is rather galling to think that all this tax-payer money, spent by tax-payer-funded staff on the "hundreds of staff-hours assisting the SPCS in their study" was for nothing more than to lay a smokescreen to hide the real IHA intentions and activities from the public, said SPCS Feasibility Committee member, Peter Van Iersel.
In its various press releases these past few days, IHA officials continue to avoid accountability and clarity by combining project announcements that confuse the public, in an attempt to wear down community resolve.
They have even gone so far as to coach key local politicians by Speaking Notes aimed at discrediting the SPCS volunteers expertise and depth of diligence. One such coaching note asks Trail Mayor Dieter Bogs to say:
Renovating KIRO to accommodate 22 beds would cost $6.8-million, not $1.5-million as suggested by the SPCS .The SPCS report was well meaning, but the very qualified facilities management staff at IH had a good look and just say it cant be done. It doesnt leave enough room for the Wellness Centre, the cost estimates look very low, what the community was really asking for was additional beds and now weve got that, I think we should let the IH get on with the Wellness Centre as quickly as possible.*
*(See attachment: IHA Speaking Notes(Nov. 21)).
How patronizing, said Carol Albo. These Speaking Notes were dated Nov. 21; three days before IHA reps (including IHA cost analyst Nicola Hippertz) sat down with SPCS cost analysts and confirmed the low estimates as accurate, especially compared to the 6.8 figure used by IHA.
IHA also confessed to us that they had never sought other, cheaper office leasing than the $500,000/yr. they are currently committed to.
Health Minister Abbotts promise that Trail would get more transition and palliative beds, was ignored by IHA. Concerned area citizens showed how to obtain these beds by reasonably renovating KIRO to still incorporate half the Wellness Centre services. But their proposal was not seriously considered.
BCTV KOOTENAYS NEWSROOM