| Year | Winners | Losers | Score | Lineup/Results | |
| 2007 | 4th & Inches | Pepsi QC | 133-58 | Lineups | |
| 2006 | Dominated Slaves | Buckeyes | 79-49 | Lineups | |
| 2005 | Gang Green | Stuck On Stupid | 89-50 | Lineups | |
| 2004 | Dominated Slaves | 4th & Inches | 120-72 | Lineups | |
| 2003 | Bristol Brawlers | Dominated Slaves | 80-55 | Lineups | |
