Site hosted by Angelfire.com: Build your free website today!

Pulse Magazine Article

Back To Main Page

Pulse October 25, 1997 SECTION: Pg. 78 LENGTH: 649 words HEADLINE: Surgery for obesity

BODY: Effective treatment of morbid obesity normalises cardiac risk factors and helps improve or resolve co-morbidity states such as diabetes and obstructive sleep apnoea. According to Mr Stephen Pollard, several studies have shown the Roux-en-Y gastric bypass to be superior to the more traditional vertical banded gastroplasty in achieving adequate and sustained weight loss.

Indications

* Morbidly obese patients aged 18-60 should be considered for surgery if their body mass index (BMI) is >40, or >35 if associated with significant obesity-related co-morbidity such as osteoarthritis, diabetes mellitus, hypertension or obstructive sleep apnoea (BMI is calculated as weight (kg)/height (m2)).

Contraindications

* Significant cardiac disease with an abnormal echocardiogram and extensive psychiatric problems in the past are relative contraindications.

* Previous vertical banded gastroplasty that has failed to achieve weight loss is not a contraindication.

Alternative treatments

* Conventional dieting will always achieve weight loss, but these patients characteristically regain all the lost weight and often overshoot as soon as the restriction is lifted.

* Jejuno-ileal bypass is now outlawed because of the high risk of liver failure from malnutrition.

* Vertical banded gastroplasty has produced disappointing long-term results in terms of function, with vomiting a frequent symptom. Weight loss is often not maintained after the first few years due to dilation of the gastric pouch or disruption of the staple line.

Availability

* Vertical banded gastroplasty is available at many centres, but the gastric bypass - in spite of its proven track record in the US - is available in only a handful of units that have a specialist interest in surgery for obesity. St James's Hospital in Leeds is the most active UK centre, performing 50-60 cases each year. Most referrals come directly from GPs.

Pre-operative work-up

* Exclusion of underlying metabolic causes for the obesity, with thyroid, adrenal and sex hormone estimations.

* Measurement of cholesterol and lipids.

* Selected patients undergo overnight monitoring for obstructive sleep apnoea.

Time in hospital/off work

* Seven days in hospital.

* Three to six weeks off work depending on physical activity required.

Complication rate in best hands

* Mortality - less than 1 per cent; generally from cardiac causes.

* Significant risk of wound infection (10 per cent) and incisional hernia formation (10 per cent).

* Leakage from or stenosis of gastroenterostomy and staple line disruption seen in less than 2 per cent.

Success rate

* All patients will lose weight. Some 10 per cent will achieve inadequate weight loss (defined as less than 40 per cent of their excess weight). Most achieve loss of two-thirds of their excess in the first year and >80 per cent after three years. Around 40 per cent will achieve and maintain their ideal body weight.

* >90 per cent of diabetics come off insulin.

* >80 per cent of hypertensives come off all treatment.

* >90 per cent of urinary incontinent patients become continent.

Post-operative care

* Diet supervised by hospital dietitian, who must stay in contact.

* Ranitidine, 150mg per day (risk of ulceration at gastroenterostomy).

* Proprietary multivitamin supplements, one per day.

* Calcium in peri- and post-menopausal females.

* Oral zinc supplements if hair loss reported (25 per cent).

Post-operative warning signs

* Early vomiting is usually caused by poor compliance.

* Delayed vomiting after meals may suggest stenosis of gastroenterostomy.

* Weight gain - very uncommon but might suggest staple line disruption or dilatation of gastroenterostomy.

Email: rouse@quiknet.com