| Across |
This page needs a bit of editing....
1. Within the
context of Islam, Muhammad was unique for having
two sides to his leadership. As a prophet, he was the spiritual leader
of the Muslims, while as the leader of Medina and the head of the
Islamic Polity, he was the political ruler of Arabia at the time of his
death.
Now, after his death, the Muslim society was
divided between two religio-political ideas.
One held that Muhammad cannot be succeeded in his capacity as a spiritual
leader, and
his successors should only be political leaders of the Islamic state. On the
other hand, a
minority reasoned that Muhammad, after 23 years of working on creating a
society based
on a belief, would not just die leaving its fate to the uncertain future.
This latter group argued
that the Islamic society needs a spiritual leader, as well as political one,
and it will be better to
keep both roles within the same person, and as such, one supposedly
sanctioned as a spiritual
authority by Muhammad himself. This latter group became the Shi'a, while the
former (with
some compromise, the more "secular" group, or those promoting a
separation
of "church"
and state) became the Sunnis.
...It of course gets complicated, but the simple answer to the question of
"what is the difference
between the Shi'a and the Sunni", is "the Shi'a believe that a society needs
both a spiritual and
political leader, while Sunnis consider the leader of the Islamic society is
only a political leader".
http://www.vishistorica.com/brain/archives/000858.php
2.
Groups with extremist beliefs have emerged from both sides.
Among those who claim to be Sunni Muslims are the Qadianies,
who believe that a person by the name of Mirza Ghulam Ahmed
appeared in the Indo-Pak subcontinent over a hundred years ago,
and that he was a prophet of Allah who received divine revelation.
Among the Shi'a there are the Abadiyyahs, who believe that 'Ali was
partly divine; the 'Alawies, who consider 'Ali virtually a prophet; and
the Druze, who consider an 11th-century descendant of 'Ali, al-Hakim,
to have been the embodiment of God. All groups that hold such views
are diametrically opposed to the agreed-upon fundamentals of Islam and
are not considered within the fold of Islam by the mainstream Shi'as and
Sunnis who constitute more than 90% of those who claim to be Muslim.
| |
Sunnah
|
Shia (or Shi'ah)
|
|
adherents called
|
Sunnis
|
Shiites, Shi'i
|
| meaning of name |
"well-trodden path" or "tradition"
|
"party" or "partisans" of Ali
|
|
current adherents
|
940 million
|
120 million
|
| percentage of total Muslims |
90%
|
10%
|
| primary locations |
most Muslim countries
|
Iran, Iraq, Yemen
|
| subsects |
none, but four major schools of Muslim law are recognized
|
Ithna 'Ashariyah (Twelvers; the largest), Isma'iliyah and
Zaydiyah
|
| origins |
c. 632 CE; theology developed especially in 10th cent.
|
c. 632-650 CE; killing of Ali's son Husayn in 680 CE is major
event
|
| did Muhammad designate a successor? |
no
|
yes
|
| true successor of the Prophet |
Abu Bakr, father of the Prophet's favoured wife, 'A'ishah
(elected by people of Medina)
|
'Ali ibn Abi Talib, husband of the Prophet's daughter Fatimah
(designated by the Prophet)
|
| qualifications for ruler of Islam |
tribe of the Prophet (Quraysh); later, any qualified ruler
|
family of the Prophet
|
| current leaders |
imams
|
mujtahids
|
| identity of imams |
human leaders
|
infallible manifestations of God and perfect interpreters of the
Qur'an
|
| Al Mahdi |
will come in the future
|
was already on earth, is currently the "hidden imam" who works
through mujtahids to intepret Qur'an; and will return at the end
of time
|
| religious authority other than the Qu'ran |
ijma' (consensus) of the Muslim community
|
infallible imams
|
| concealing faith for self-protection (taqiya) |
affirmed under certain circumstances
|
emphasized
|
| temporarymarriage (mut'ah) (multiplewives) |
practiced in the Prophet's time, but now rejected
|
still practiced
|
| holy cities |
|
|
| major holidays |
|
|
|
Until |