|
Is US
Healthcare a Constitutional Right?
by Tim Flanagan, facilitator for www.WritingResource.info
Preamble to the US Constitution
"We the People(1) of
the United States, in Order to form a
more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic
Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote
the
general welfare,(2) and
secure the Blessings of Liberty to
ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this
Constitution for the United States of America."
Notes: http://healthcareandeducation.blogspot.com/
- The Preamble declares that:
"We the People of the United States ....
do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of
America."
The meaning is clear that all authority originates from the People.
- "general welfare," as used in the Constitution, refers to: "health, happiness,
or prosperity; well-being. [Middle English wel
faren, to fare well]"
We pay more for less
Life expectancy for those born in Canada is about two years higher than for
those born in the USA. Medical costs as a percentage of GDP are 15 percent
in the USA and 10 percent in the Canadian single-payer system.
American
"health care" costs 2 trillion dollars and leaves upwards of 50

million
Americans uninsured: 24 million Americans are diabetic,
5.7
million have forms of congestive heart failure, 17 million have coronary
artery
disease, 22 million have asthma, and 18 million suffer from depression.
Michael Morrow, (American Federation of Teachers VP for Political Action,
Local 2277) recently noted that, "The
right-wing has convinced people
that
these are personal issues." But lost work days,
reduced productivity, and
costs to families, businesses, and communities
makes our failed system
a national security
issue. The United States of America is the
only western
industrialized country
which does not provide universal, government-supported
healthcare for the
well-being of all citizens.
Ricardo
Alonzo -Zaldiver, writing for the Associated Press, reminds us that
if
the
50 million "uninsured were a political lobbying group, they would be
larger
than
AARP.” Yet too many characterize going without health insurance as
a personal issue, a misfortune, or “ achoice.”
Yet
when problems related to health and our healthcare delivery system
impact our nation’s ability to compete in the global marketplace, this must
no longer be seen as some unfortunate personal choice. Many of the uninsured
and
under-insured do not have the time or resources to lobby for solutions, but
there are advocates for these millions of uninsured Americans. Unions and
aging Americans are taking action. Health Care for America Now plans
to bring 15 thousand or more Americans to Washington this year to lobby
Congress for guaranteed health insurance. This is a start.
Perhaps Health Insurance is the Problem
Others say health insurance may itself be our biggest problem. Incremental
reforms in multi-payer financing systems, which require expensive marketing
and
prohibitive administrative costs, will not help the growing number of
Americans who have no insurance and no place to turn.
Leonard Rodberg noted in The Portland Observer that
"Multi-payer systems are unable to control costs. The only way
to assure cost containment is to adopt a unified financing mechanism
that has the leverage to negotiate lower prices."
A unified single payer system can provide the necessary pool of people
to lower costs, plus
budgeting and planning
tools which will save money
while protecting
all of our people, all of the time.
40
percent of American working people (including those with insurance)
are
struggling to pay medical bills. Yet most leading Democrats,
including President
Obama, would continue to allow transnational
insurance
cartels to define, control, and set the costs for our health
care
delivery system.
The
administrative cost savings of a single-payer system would
be
enough to cover all of the uninsured as well as lower costs for
those who are currently
insured. This approach is favored by working
people, labor
unions, and medical doctors. This "expanded Medicare”
has
majority support and more of our legislators are taking a closer look.
A Man with A Plan
Dennis Kucinich and other legislators have proposed a plan for reconstructing
our health care delivery
system so that it is more in synch with the social, political,
and economic realities of today. Kucinich explains:
"The
underlying problem is that we treat health care like a market commodity
instead of a social service. Health care is targeted not to medical need, but
to
the ability to pay. Markets are good for many things, but they are not a good
way
to distribute health care…"
Mainstream"
writers like Ph. D. economist and columnist for the New York
Times Paul Krugman now agree with those doctors and Dennis that "covering
everyone under Medicare would actually be significantly cheaper than our
current system. "They all recognize that we already spend enough to
provide
national health care to all but lack the political courage to make the tough
decisions that doctors, nurses and medical professionals must run our health
care system, – not "for profit" insurance companies who make money by
denying health care.
It
is time to recognize that all the civilized countries have a solution that we
must adapt to this country. American businesses can no longer be competitive
shouldering the entire cost of health care. Health care is a right that all
Americans deserve."
The United States ranks
37th in the World Health Organization’s
rankings of the world’s health systems (below Malta, Iceland, Saudi
Arabia, and numerous other countries that might surprise you) This means
36 poorer and less-developed countries take better
care of their people.
We can do better.
Take
a look at this Healthcare
Press-release on a PDX Heathcare Forum
and here is a place to explore Universal Health
Care Issues & Options
Onward Oregon on Healthcare / An
update!
|