I expect all of the fics to be tragic in some way, but this category is for those fics that make the reader feel that the world is just not fair.
Category for fics that are going to give me a heart attack figuring out how they may end.
For those fics where I say, "damn, I did NOT see that coming..."
I can't imagine a contest geared for the evil that doesn't have at least one fic that will make me afraid to sleep at night. Bring it on baby!
For fics that have a somber theme, with humor sprinkled here and there...
For fics whose depictions of Duo/Quatre are well-rounded. Not because they're being bad for the sake of being bad.
Category for best fic overall. (Duh!)