Permanent Magnet Repulsion Coil Gun

Email: sixmhz@yahoo.com
Link to my Homepage
Link to main Coil Gun page
Link to the X-Gun low energy coil gun page
Link to a High Energy Coil gun page
Link to velocity determination circuitry, Event timer

Introduction

For a new twist on coil guns, I've decided to try to enhance the performance by utilizing Neodymium Iron Boron magnets. These permanent magnets will directly take the place of the nominal ferrite content projectile. By using magnets, the attraction/repulsion force will be immediately increased due to the field interaction of the magnet (magnets attract other magnets better than anything else). The second trick I'm pulling is that the repulsive force rather than the attractive force will be utilized for acceleration. By utilizing the repulsive force, the benefits are two fold. First, the "suck-back" effect inherent to coil guns is essentially eliminated. This benefit alone should increase the efficiency significantly. Second, by using repulsive forces the peak acceleration forces will be magnified because the minimum distance between the coil and the projectile will occur as the peak current passes, not after. I will show these effects by numerical simulation in Excel.

Since traditional ferrite projectiles may only be attracted to an electromagnetic field and never repelled, only permanent magnets are suitable for a repulsion design.

Nominal Coil Gun Simulation

To the right is a figure resulting from the numerical simulation I made with Excel. This figure shows the coil current, acceleration force, and the distance from the projectile to the center of the coil. For this simulation the projectile was assumed to be a point mass and the coil was assumed to be a point charge. Both the x and y axis have arbitrary units, the x axis being time. The coil is assumed to be purely resistive with no inductive qualities. These simulations do not yield quantitative results, but the trends shown should be representative of typical systems.

At time zero, the capacitor bank is discharged as a large current passes through the coil. This figure shows that the current decays exponentially with time.

Since the force of acceleration is inversely proportional to the square of the distance, the force is really only "active" as the distance nears zero, or the center of the coil. Notice how the best potential acceleration force (when the current is at its peak) is wasted because the projectile is too far away to be affected optimally. To utilize this peak current and force, the projectile can be initially placed closer to the center of the coil, but doing so increases the suck-back effect.

The figure shows an inflection point in the force curve as the projectile passes through the center of the coil where the projectile now begins to experience "suck-back" or a force in the decelerating direction. The amount of suck-back is the portion of the force curve that dips below zero, essentially everything after the projectile passes the center of the coil. Since the area of forward acceleration force (above zero on the y axis) is greater than the area of suck-back acceleration, the net acceleration is forward and the projectile rockets out of the gun.

The slope of the "distance" curve is the velocity of the projectile. After the projectile leaves the coil and is far enough from the dissipating electromagnetic field, its velocity is constant as it travels through the rest of the barrel.

In order to optimize this type of accelerator, care must be taken to determine the best starting position. The starting position must maximize the most peak acceleration force (by starting the projectile closer to the center of the coil) but also minimize the suck-back force (by moving the projectile further from the center of the coil). Tricky business! With such a design, acceleration and efficiency will always suffer greatly.

Permanent Magnet Simulation

The figure to the right shows a simulation in which a magnetic projectile utilizing a repulsive type acceleration system is used. Again the current curve decays exponentially with time as before. It is easy to see that there are significant differences in the profiles of the distance and force curves.

A study of the force curve in this diagram shows several significant improvements over the traditional coil gun design. First notice that there is NO suck-back effect after the projectile is at a minimum distance from the coil center. This is because the magnetic projectile is being repelled from the coil and is never sucked-back towards it. This result alone should improve coil gun results significantly.

With no suck-back effect, we are no longer limited by only net acceleration and allowed to move the starting position of the projectile as close to the center of the coil as we like. This lets us optimize the forward acceleration, allowing utilization of the peak coil current.

The results of these simulations are very promising and may lead to a new breed of coil guns with significantly greater efficiencies that require less optimization.

Current Design

Recently purchased some 0.125" diameter X 0.5" magnets for small prototype testing. The major concern that has come up so far is that the coil actually realigns the spins of the electrons in the magnet. I have been able to completely reverse the polarity of the "permanent" magnets. This result could seriously threaten the likely hood of this project being successful.

Last updated: 9/28/02
Copyright 2002, Greg Miller
http://www.angelfire.com/80s/sixmhz/magnetgun.html